MLSSports Illustrated StadiumSaturday, May 16, 2026, 11:30 PM UTC
Kickoff in 21d 10h 54m
New York Red Bulls
vs
New York City FC
AI Pick: New York City FC Win
Confidence: 58%
1X2: New York City FC Win (58%)
O/U 2.5: Over 2.5 Goals
BTTS: Yes
Get $5 Free Bet โ No Deposit Required
Bet New York City FC Win ยท AI confidence 58%
18+ ยท Play Responsibly ยท Predictify Sports may earn commission ยท Affiliate disclosure
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC Prediction
This Hudson River Derby promises to be a competitive clash between two Eastern Conference rivals currently tied on points. New York City FC holds a slight edge based on recent head-to-head results and a better goal difference, despite facing significant attacking injuries. New York Red Bulls, playing at home, will need to overcome their defensive vulnerabilities. Expect a high-scoring affair.
MATCH RESULT
New York City FC Win
Predicted: 1-2
58%
New York City FC holds a strong recent head-to-head advantage in the Hudson River Derby, including two away wins in the last five meetings. Despite both teams having inconsistent form and injury concerns, NYCFC's superior goal difference and stronger defensive rating from API-Sports give them a slight edge. The API-Sports prediction explicitly suggests a 'Win or draw' for NYCFC, with equal probability for both outcomes. Given the instruction to favor a slight favorite over a draw when in doubt, and NYCFC's recent derby performance, an away win is predicted. The confidence is moderate due to the derby's unpredictable nature, NYRB's home advantage, and NYCFC's significant attacking injuries.
TOTAL GOALS
Over 2.5 Goals
Total: 3.0
60%
Both teams have been involved in high-scoring games recently, with New York Red Bulls' last four matches seeing over 2.5 goals. NYRB's home games average 4.5 goals per game, and NYCFC's away games average 2.33 goals per game. NYRB's leaky defense (2.3 goals conceded at home) combined with NYCFC's decent attack suggests multiple goals. Both teams are likely to score given their offensive capabilities and defensive vulnerabilities.
BOTH TEAMS TO SCORE
Yes
55%
Both teams have been involved in high-scoring games recently, with New York Red Bulls' last four matches seeing over 2.5 goals. NYRB's home games average 4.5 goals per game, and NYCFC's away games average 2.33 goals per game. NYRB's leaky defense (2.3 goals conceded at home) combined with NYCFC's decent attack suggests multiple goals. Both teams are likely to score given their offensive capabilities and defensive vulnerabilities.
๐ More Markets
โฝ Goal Markets
Total Goals (O/U 1.5)
Over 1.5
Both teams have high-scoring tendencies and defensive vulnerabilities. The API-Sports advice explicitly includes '+1.5 goals', indicating a very high probability of at least two goals in the match.
Total Goals (O/U 3.5)
Over 3.5
New York Red Bulls' recent games have been very high-scoring (e.g., 4-4, 4-1 loss, 2-2, 4-2 win, 6-1 loss), and New York City FC also recently had a 4-4 draw. This suggests a strong likelihood of more than 3 goals.
1st Half Goals (O/U 0.5)
Over 0.5
Both teams have shown a tendency to score and concede in the first half. Given the expected open nature of the game and recent high-scoring trends, at least one goal in the first half is highly probable.
First Team to Score
Away
New York City FC has a slightly better overall attack and NYRB's defense has been particularly vulnerable, especially at home. This makes NYCFC more likely to open the scoring.
Goal in Both Halves
Yes
Given the expectation of multiple goals and both teams' offensive capabilities, it is likely that goals will be scored in both halves of the match.
Most Likely Score
1-2
Based on NYCFC's slight favoritism, their lower away scoring average (1.0 GF/game), and NYRB's high home goals conceded (2.3 GA/game), a narrow 1-2 victory for NYCFC is a plausible outcome, also reflecting a recent derby score.
BTTS 1st Half
Yes
While less common, the high-scoring nature of recent games for both teams, coupled with defensive weaknesses, makes both teams scoring in the first half a plausible, albeit riskier, outcome in this derby.
xG Based (O/U 2.5)
Over 2.5 xG
Given the expectation of Over 2.5 actual goals and both teams' offensive output, it is reasonable to expect a combined xG (Expected Goals) of over 2.5 for the match.
๐ Result Markets
Double Chance
X2
The API-Sports prediction strongly advises a 'Win or draw' for New York City FC, with 45% probability for both a draw and an away win. This aligns with NYCFC's recent H2H dominance and overall slight favoritism.
Draw No Bet
Away
Given New York City FC is the slight favorite and the API-Sports prediction leans towards them winning or drawing, backing NYCFC on a Draw No Bet market provides a safer option.
HT/FT
Draw/Away
Derby matches can often start cautiously, leading to a draw at halftime. Given NYCFC's slight edge and their ability to finish strong, a Draw at halftime followed by an Away win is a reasonable prediction.
๐ Team Stats
Total Corners (O/U 9.5)
Over 9.5
New York Red Bulls average 7.1 corners per game, and New York City FC average 4.1-4.4 corners per game. The combined average suggests a high number of corners in this derby match.
Total Cards (O/U 3.5)
Over 3.5
Derby matches are typically intense and physical, leading to more fouls and cards. Both teams average around 1.3-1.7 yellow cards per game, making Over 3.5 cards a reasonable expectation.
Shots on Target (O/U 8.5)
Over 8.5
New York Red Bulls average 5.8-6.4 shots on target, and New York City FC average 5.6-5.9 shots on target. Given the attacking nature of both teams and their defensive weaknesses, a combined total over 8.5 is likely.
Total Shots (O/U 22.5)
Over 22.5
New York Red Bulls average 14.9-15.9 shots per game, and New York City FC average 12.3-13.6 shots per game. A combined total exceeding 22.5 shots is expected given their attacking styles.
Total Fouls (O/U 22.5)
Over 22.5
Derby matches are often fiercely contested, leading to a higher number of fouls. Both teams average around 12-13 fouls per game, making a combined total over 22.5 likely.
Possession Winner
Home
New York Red Bulls tend to have slightly more possession at home, averaging 55.6-56.7% compared to New York City FC's 53.7-54% average possession.
New York Red Bulls Clean Sheet
No
New York Red Bulls have only kept one clean sheet at home in four games and concede an average of 2.3 goals per home game. New York City FC has not kept an away clean sheet in three games. Both teams have leaky defenses, making clean sheets unlikely for either side.
New York City FC Clean Sheet
No
New York Red Bulls have only kept one clean sheet at home in four games and concede an average of 2.3 goals per home game. New York City FC has not kept an away clean sheet in three games. Both teams have leaky defenses, making clean sheets unlikely for either side.
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC โ Key Stats
Sports Illustrated Stadium
Home Ground
11:30 PM UTC
Saturday, May 16
Matchday kickoff
MLS
Soccer
Betting Angles โ New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC
๐ฐ Sharp Money
No specific sharp money data is available, but the lack of odds suggests the market is still forming or highly volatile for this derby. Line movement: N/A (no initial odds provided to track movement)
AI Same Game Parlay โ New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC
๐ฅ RECOMMENDED SGP
3-LegCombined Odds: 6.36 (+536)
AI Confidence: 20%
$10 โ $63.64 | $25 โ $159.10 | $50 โ $318.20
Correlation: POSITIVE โ โ all legs support each other
Risk Assessment
High Risk- โ ๏ธMLS matches are inherently unpredictable, especially derby games.
- โ ๏ธBoth teams have inconsistent recent form and significant injury concerns.
- โ ๏ธNew York Red Bulls' poor home defensive record.
- โ ๏ธNew York City FC's significant attacking injuries could limit their scoring potential.
- โ ๏ธConflicting form metrics from different sources add to uncertainty.
Model Confidence
โก65%
Data quality: Good, comprehensive team statistics, standings, H2H, and recent news/injury reports were available through Google Search and provided data.
Limitations
- โขLack of real-time bookmaker odds for value bet analysis.
- โขSpecific starting lineups for the match date are not yet available.
- โขSome injury updates are from earlier in the season, and exact recovery timelines can be fluid.
This prediction is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It does not constitute betting advice.
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC โ FAQ
In 32 meetings across all competitions, the New York Red Bulls have won 16 times, New York City FC has won 12 times, and there have been 4 draws.