MLBMonday, May 18, 2026, 11:15 PM UTC
Game starts in 2d 21h 28m
Mets
vs
Yankees
AI Confidence: 57%
Winner: Yankees Win (57%)
Spread: Yankees -1.5 (-1.5) (54%)
Total: Under 8.5 (60%)
Get $5 Free Bet โ No Deposit Required
Bet Yankees Win ยท AI confidence 57%
18+ ยท Play Responsibly ยท Predictify Sports may earn commission ยท Affiliate disclosure
Mets vs Yankees Prediction
This hypothetical Subway Series matchup would pit the struggling but talented Yankees against an injury-plagued Mets team on a surprising hot streak. Key factors include the impact of injuries on the Mets' offense and the reliability of both bullpens, which have been strong this season. The Yankees' overall superior record gives them a slight edge, despite their recent dip in form.
Mets host Yankees on Monday, part of the 2026 MLB season. Both teams' season records, recent form, and matchup-specific factors are detailed in the stats and prediction sections below.
ATS PREDICTION
Yankees Win
Predicted: 5-4
57%
The Yankees, despite a recent cold streak, hold a significantly better overall season record (27-17) compared to the Mets (18-25). While the Mets are on a hot streak, winning 8 of their last 12 games, they are severely hampered by a long list of key injuries, including Francisco Lindor, Luis Robert, Jorge Polanco, Francisco รlvarez, Ronny Mauricio, and Kodai Senga. The Yankees' bullpen, despite some concerns with Camilo Doval, generally boasts a strong ERA (3.28, second in MLB), while the Mets' bullpen has also performed well this season (3.54 ERA, 6th in MLB). Assuming a hypothetical matchup with mid-tier starters due to both teams' aces likely having pitched earlier in the series, the Yankees' deeper roster and overall season consistency should give them a slight edge, even on the road. The Mets' offensive production will likely be limited by their numerous injured regulars.
SPREAD PREDICTION
Yankees -1.5 (-1.5)
54%
Considering the Yankees' superior overall record and the Mets' substantial injury list, the Yankees are expected to win by at least two runs. The Mets' recent winning streak has come against weaker opponents or under specific pitching matchups that may not apply to a hypothetical game against the stronger Yankees lineup. The Yankees' offense, while in a slump, has the power to break through against a potentially unproven Mets starter.
TOTAL PREDICTION
Under 8.5
60%
Both the Mets (3.54 ERA, 6th in MLB) and Yankees (3.28 ERA, 2nd in MLB) bullpens have demonstrated strong performances this season, which should help keep the scoring in check. With a hypothetical matchup of mid-rotation starters and the Mets dealing with significant offensive injuries, runs are likely to be at a premium for both sides.
๐ More Markets
๐ Additional Markets
First 5 Innings Winner
New York Yankees
Assuming the Yankees' hypothetical starter is slightly more consistent early in the game compared to the Mets' depth starter, the Yankees could build an early lead before bullpens take over.
Total Home Runs
Under 2.5
With strong bullpens and potentially non-ace starters for both teams, combined with Citi Field being less of a hitter's park, home runs are expected to be limited.
New York Yankees Team Total Runs
Over 4.5
Despite their recent slump, the Yankees possess significant offensive talent, especially with Aaron Judge in the lineup. They are capable of scoring at least 5 runs even against a decent pitcher.
New York Mets Team Total Runs
Under 3.5
The Mets' lineup is severely depleted by injuries to key players like Lindor, Robert, and Alvarez, which will significantly hinder their scoring potential against a capable Yankees pitching staff.
Player to Get a Hit
Aaron Judge (NYY)
Aaron Judge is a consistent hitter (.268 average, 42 hits this season) and a cornerstone of the Yankees' offense. He is likely to get at least one hit in this matchup.
Player to Get a Hit
Carson Benge (NYM)
Rookie Carson Benge has been on a hot streak for the Mets in May, batting .341 with 14 hits in 13 games, making him a strong candidate for a hit in this game.
Mets vs Yankees โ Key Stats (AI)
No recent head-to-head meetings on record for this matchup.
Betting Angles โ Mets vs Yankees
โ Moneyline: New York Mets
While the Mets are on a good run, their injury woes are significant. The model slightly disagrees with these implied odds, seeing slightly less value.
โ Total Runs: Under 8.5
Both teams feature strong bullpens this season, and with potential mid-rotation starters and the Mets' injured lineup, a lower-scoring affair is probable. The model sees significant edge on the under.
๐ฐ Sharp Money
Potentially on Mets (+1.5 or ML), given their recent hot streak and the high variance of MLB, creating value against the favored Yankees. Line movement: Initial lines might favor the Yankees, but if the Mets continue their strong play leading up to this hypothetical game, we could see a slight shift towards the Mets, or increased money on the total 'under' given bullpen strengths.
AI Same Game Parlay โ Mets vs Yankees
๐ฅ RECOMMENDED SGP
3-LegCombined Odds: 5.96 (+496)
AI Confidence: 55%
$10 โ $59.60 | $25 โ $149.00 | $50 โ $298.00
Correlation: positive
Risk Assessment
High Risk- โ ๏ธLack of confirmed starting pitchers for a hypothetical May 18th game.
- โ ๏ธSignificant injury impact on the Mets' lineup affecting offensive output.
- โ ๏ธThe Yankees' recent cold streak adds uncertainty to their performance.
- โ ๏ธInherent high variance in MLB games, especially divisional rivalry games.
Data Quality Score
58%
Data quality: Medium
Limitations
- โขThis prediction is for a hypothetical Mets vs Yankees game on May 18, 2026, as search results indicate both teams are scheduled to play different opponents on this date.
- โขSpecific starting pitchers and exact betting lines for a future hypothetical game are not available and thus are assumed based on general team and pitcher performance around the given date.
- โขInjuries and player form are based on reports up to May 15, 2026, and could change.
This prediction is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It does not constitute betting advice.
Mets vs Yankees โ FAQ
No, according to available schedules, the New York Mets are scheduled to play the Washington Nationals on May 18, 2026, while the New York Yankees are set to face the Toronto Blue Jays on the same date.
Our MLB predictions weigh starting pitcher matchups, bullpen depth, lineup form, ballpark factors, and weather. Baseball is structurally high-variance โ confidence rarely exceeds 65% on the moneyline even with a clear pitching edge. See the full methodology and other matches on our AI MLB Picks hub.